What's Really Warming the World?
Skeptics of manmade climate change offer various natural causes to explain why
the Earth has warmed 1.4 degrees
Fahrenheit since 1880. But can these account for the planet's rising temperature? Scroll down to
see
how much different factors, both natural and industrial, contribute to global warming, based on
findings
from NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies.
Is It the Earth's Orbit?
The Earth wobbles on its axis, and its tilt and orbit change over many thousands
of years, pushing the climate
into and out of ice ages. Yet the influence of orbital changes on the planet's temperature over
125
years has been negligible.
Is It the Sun?
The sun's temperature varies over decades and centuries. These changes have
had little effect on the Earth's
overall climate.
Is It Volcanoes?
The data suggest no. Human industry emits about 100 times more CO
2 than volcanic activity, and eruptions release sulfate chemicals that can actually cool
the atmosphere
for a year or two.
Is it All Three of These Things Combined?
If it were, then the response to natural factors should match the observed
temperature. Adding the natural
factors together just doesn't add up.
So If It's Not Nature, Is It Deforestation?
Humans have cut, plowed, and paved more than half the Earth's land surface.
Dark forests are yielding
to lighter patches, which reflect more sunlight—and have a slight cooling effect.
Or Ozone Pollution?
Natural ozone high in the atmosphere blocks harmful sunlight and cools things
slightly. Closer to Earth,
ozone is created by pollution and traps heat, making the climate a little bit hotter. What's the
overall
effect? Not much.
Or Aerosol Pollution?
Some pollutants cool the atmosphere, like sulfate aerosols from coal-burning.
These aerosols offset some
of the warming. (Unfortunately, they also cause acid rain.)
No, It Really Is Greenhouse Gases.
Atmospheric CO
2 levels are 40 percent higher than they were in 1750. The green line shows the
influence of greenhouse
gas emissions. It's no contest.
See for Yourself
Greenhouse gases warm the atmosphere. Aerosols cool it a little bit. Ozone and
land-use changes add and subtract
a little. Together they match the observed temperature, particularly since 1950.
Compare and Contrast
Putting the possible natural and human causes of climate change alongside one
another makes the dominant
role of greenhouse gases even more plainly visible. The only real question is: What are we going to
do
about it?